Why New Managers Struggle: Understanding the First Leadership Promotion
Remember the day you found out you got promoted to manager? There was that initial rush of excitement—recognition for your hard work, validation of your skills, probably a bump in salary. But if you're honest, there was also something else: a knot of anxiety in your stomach. Because somewhere in the back of your mind, you realized that everything was about to change.
Now, you're no longer one of the team. You're the boss. The people you used to grab lunch with and vent to about management decisions? You're now the management they'll be talking about. The work you loved doing and excelled at? That's someone else's job now. This shift from individual contributor to leader of others is one of the most significant career transitions you'll make. And if it feels harder than you expected, you're not alone.
The Leadership Pipeline: Passage One
Ram Charan, Stephen Drotter, and James Noel wrote a book, The Leadership Pipeline, that maps out the major leadership transitions people go through in their careers. The first passage in that pipeline—the one we're discussing here—is the move from managing yourself to managing others.
This first passage is considered the hardest transition in the entire leadership pipeline, which often surprises people because the new role is fundamentally different from the old one. You’re no longer doing what you were already doing well. Instead, you need completely different skills, different measures of success, and different daily work. The technical expertise, deep focus, and personal productivity that made you successful as an individual contributor won't necessarily translate to success as a manager. In fact, if you keep operating the same way, you'll likely struggle.
This transition serves as the foundation for all future leadership growth. If you don't navigate this passage well, every subsequent leadership transition becomes more difficult. It's not just a title change or a pay increase. It requires fundamental shifts in how you work, how you think, and how you relate to the people around you.
Four Key Challenges
While there are many challenges as you navigate this shift, here are four main ones.
Challenge 1: The Peer-to-Leader Shift
The relationship dynamics with your former colleagues become complicated overnight. You're now responsible for performance reviews, difficult feedback, and holding people accountable—including people you were commiserating with before. The casual camaraderie that existed before now requires boundaries and limitations.
This shift can bring unexpected isolation. Your access to confidential information means you can't be as transparent as you once were. Team social events feel different when you're "the boss" in the room. Even well-meaning attempts to maintain previous friendships can create perceptions of favoritism that undermine your credibility with the broader team. You need to defend decisions you may not support.
Many new managers try to still operate in the peer realm which rarely works. The relationship has changed whether you acknowledge it or not. The challenge is figuring out how to be fair, consistent, and respectful while accepting that some distance is inevitable. You're looking for a middle ground between being authoritarian and being too familiar—and that equilibrium is difficult to find.
Challenge 2: From Doing to Delegating
As an individual contributor, you built your reputation on delivering quality work yourself. Your instinct when facing a challenge was to roll up your sleeves and solve it. Now, your job is to enable others to solve problems, even when you could do it faster or better yourself.
This creates a persistent internal conflict. Delegation takes time—explaining the context, answering questions, reviewing work, providing feedback. In the moment, it genuinely is more efficient to just handle it yourself. But leadership requires building capacity in others.
The complexity deepens when you consider which mistakes to allow. Some errors are valuable learning opportunities; others could damage client relationships or derail important projects. New managers often struggle with this judgment call. They either micromanage everything to prevent any mistakes, or they're too hands-off and let preventable problems occur. Finding the right level of involvement for each situation and each team member requires calibration that only comes with experience and, often, some trial and error.
Challenge 3: The Promotion Paradox
Being exceptional at your job doesn't automatically make you well-suited for managing others who do that job. The skill sets are distinct. A brilliant software engineer may have no interest in coaching other engineers. A top-performing salesperson may find the administrative aspects of sales management tedious and unfulfilling.
Yet in many organizations, management remains the primary—or the only—path to career advancement and higher earnings (or even recognition and growth). This creates a scenario where people accept management roles for the wrong reasons: more money, higher status, or simply because they don't see other options for growth.
The disconnect becomes apparent quickly. If you found deep satisfaction in the technical aspects of your work—the craft of it, the problem-solving, the expertise you'd developed—you may find management feels like a step away from what you actually enjoy. The skills that defined your success before (individual technical excellence, ability to concentrate deeply on complex problems) aren't the skills that will define your success now. For some people, this misalignment leads to genuine regret about accepting the promotion in the first place.
Challenge 4: Time Allocation Shock
The transformation in how you spend your days can be shocking. Where you once had blocks of time for focused project work, your calendar now fragments into smaller pieces: recurring one-on-ones, impromptu conversations about problems, meetings to align with other departments, time spent reviewing and providing feedback on others' work.
This work often feels intangible, and at the end of a day filled with meetings and conversations, it's easy to wonder what you actually accomplished. There's no finished product to point to, no problem definitively solved, no deliverable completed. The work of management—listening, asking good questions, coaching, removing roadblocks, making decisions about priorities—doesn't produce the same visible outputs you're used to.
The dopamine hit of completing a task or shipping a project is largely gone, which can impact your job satisfaction. Instead, you're dealing with slower-moving outcomes: a team member's gradual improvement over months, the long-term impact of a structural change you implemented, the cumulative effect of many small coaching moments. Adjusting to this different rhythm and learning to recognize the value in work that feels invisible takes considerable time.
Four Tips for Success
It may seem like accepting that promotion is a recipe for dissatisfaction, however, there are ways to improve your success and enjoyment of the new role.
Tip 1: Make the Mindset Shift from Doing to Managing
The most important adjustment you can make is recognizing—and truly accepting—that you have a different job now. Your contribution is no longer measured by your individual output. Success means building a team that can deliver results without you being the one doing the work.
This requires protecting time for management activities. Schedule regular one-on-ones (and protect that time; even when you're busy). Create space in your calendar for strategic thinking. Block time for planning and for reflecting on what's working and what needs to change.
Treat these management activities with the same priority you once gave to project deadlines. If you had critical one-on-ones scheduled for Tuesday mornings, defend that time as vigorously as you would have defended time needed to meet a client deadline. The work is different now, but it's no less important. Without intentional calendar management, you'll find yourself constantly in reactive mode, neither managing effectively nor contributing individually—a frustrating middle ground that serves no one well.
Tip 2: Redefine Your Success Metrics
You need to fundamentally shift how you evaluate your success. The old scorecard—tasks completed, projects delivered, problems solved personally—no longer applies. Your new measures of success look entirely different.
Start paying attention to your team's growth in capability. Are they handling situations now that they would have escalated to you three months ago? Are they solving increasingly complex problems independently? When team members achieve wins, recognize that as your success. Has your team met completed a major project. Their accomplishments reflect your effectiveness as a manager.
This shift in measurement requires patience because the feedback loop is longer. The impact of a coaching conversation you have today might not be evident for weeks or months. The person you're investing in developing may not show dramatic improvement for quite some time. You're playing a longer game now, and the satisfaction that comes from it is more delayed and more subtle than what you experienced as an individual contributor. Your legacy in this role will be defined by the people you developed and the collective capability of your team, not by the work you personally produced.
Tip 3: Invest in the Relationship Shift Intentionally
Pretending the peer-to-manager transition isn't awkward doesn't make it true—it just makes it unaddressed. The most effective approach is to acknowledge the change directly with your former peers. "Name it to tame it" by having explicit conversations about the new dynamic.
These conversations might feel uncomfortable, but they're valuable. You might open with something like: "This is a weird situation. Our working relationship is different now, and I want to talk about how we navigate that." This kind of directness allows you to set clear expectations, establish necessary boundaries, and demonstrate that you still value and respect the person—just within a different professional context.
The critical element here is consistency. Your team will watch carefully to see whether you show favoritism toward people you were previously close with. They'll notice if you're harder on some people than others, or if you avoid giving difficult feedback to former friends. Fair treatment doesn't always mean identical treatment, but it does mean applying consistent standards and being willing to have tough conversations with everyone when needed. How you handle these relationships sets the tone for your credibility as a manager.
Tip 4: Adopt a Growth Mindset
Management is a learnable skill, not an innate talent that some people possess and others don't. Approach it the same way you approached building expertise in your technical area: with curiosity, intentional practice, and patience for the learning process.
Invest in your development as a manager. Read widely on leadership and management topics. Seek out workshops or courses. Find a mentor who has navigated this transition successfully and can offer perspective when you're struggling. Connect with other managers—particularly other new managers—who can relate to what you're experiencing and share what they're learning.
Be deliberate about practicing new skills. After an important conversation, reflect on what worked and what didn't. Try different approaches to coaching and see what gets results. Ask your team for feedback on your management style and really listen to what they tell you. Build relationships with people who can serve as sounding boards when you're not sure how to handle a situation.
Remember that you weren't excellent at your previous role from day one. You developed competence through repeated practice, feedback, and learning from mistakes. The same process applies here. Give yourself permission to be a beginner at this new craft while committing to continuous improvement.
Moving Forward
This transition is genuinely difficult, and struggling with it doesn't mean you're failing—it means you're navigating one of the most substantial career shifts you'll encounter. Everything about your work changes: your daily activities, your relationships, how you create value, and what gives you a sense of accomplishment.
The encouraging part is that the skills required for effective management can be learned and developed. This isn't about possessing some innate leadership quality. It's about deliberately building new capabilities through practice, feedback, and reflection. Be realistic about the learning curve while also being intentional about your development.
When you successfully make this transition, the work offers its own distinct rewards. There's genuine fulfillment in watching people develop capabilities they didn't know they had, in building a team that functions effectively, and in creating an environment where people do their best work. That's the opportunity available to you as you navigate this challenging passage.
What’s Next:
Read these related blog posts:
Sign up for my free Leadership Toolbox
Want to learn more?
Listen to this related radio show:
Click the image to visit the show page where you can learn more and listen to the episode.
